Key points
- Strengthening should follow an audit and re-analysis that shows which members lack strength or stiffness.
- Concrete jacketing adds a lot of strength, but also size, weight and stiffness.
- CFRP is light and quick to install, but works only as tensile reinforcement and is very sensitive to heat.
- Steel bracing improves the global stiffness of a building, for example when storey drift is too large.
Structural strengthening is needed when beams, columns, slabs or the seismic system can no longer carry the required loads. The cause may be damage, a change of use, an added floor, or design standards that have moved on since the building was built. This article explains three widely used methods, jacketing, CFRP and steel bracing, and how engineers choose between them.
When structural strengthening is needed
Strengthening is never the first step. The decision comes from a structural assessment: building data is collected, materials are tested, and the capacity of each member is recalculated against design loads and earthquakes. Common triggers include:
- A change of use, such as offices turned into archive or storage space with much heavier floor loads.
- An added floor or heavy rooftop plant, such as chillers or water tanks. See also what to check before adding a floor.
- Damage from fire, earthquakes or reinforcement corrosion.
- Concrete weaker than specified, found through rebound hammer tests and core drilling.
- A seismic evaluation of an older building against SNI 1726:2019 that shows a lack of strength or stiffness.
The analysis tells you what is missing: flexural strength, shear strength, column axial capacity, ductility, or overall stiffness. That diagnosis drives the choice of method.
Concrete and steel jacketing
Jacketing means wrapping an existing member in a new layer. With concrete jacketing, extra reinforcement is placed around a column or beam and a new concrete layer is cast. A review in Structural Durability & Health Monitoring notes that concrete jackets are typically more than 70–100 mm thick and can raise the member's mass by about 20–45%.
The gain in strength can be large, and local contractors know the materials well. The downsides:
- Columns get bigger, so usable space shrinks.
- Formwork and casting make the work slow.
- Weight and stiffness increase. Higher stiffness can shorten the building's period and attract larger seismic forces, so the seismic analysis must be repeated.
Steel jacketing uses steel plates or sections around the column. It is usually quicker to install than concrete jacketing, but the steel needs corrosion and fire protection, and it still needs clearance around the member.
CFRP: thin and light strengthening
CFRP (carbon fibre reinforced polymer) is a carbon fibre sheet or strip bonded to the concrete surface with epoxy resin. The guide most often used for its design is ACI 440.2R-17. The same review notes that FRP typically adds less than 2% to a member's mass, so it barely changes the building's weight or stiffness.
CFRP is used to increase the bending and shear strength of beams and slabs, and to wrap columns for confinement. ACI 440.2R-17 sets some important limits:
- FRP counts only as tensile reinforcement, never as compression reinforcement.
- The strength gain is capped, so that if the FRP is damaged or debonds, the member does not fail suddenly.
- FRP strength is assumed to be lost in a fire unless shown otherwise, for example with protective coatings or insulation.
- For bond-critical work, the concrete must not be too weak (at least 17 MPa) and its surface tensile strength is checked with a pull-off test (at least 1.4 MPa).
- FRP does not stop reinforcement corrosion. Corrosion must be dealt with and damaged concrete repaired first.
Tip: CFRP depends heavily on surface preparation and installer skill. Make sure the method statement, pull-off tests and site inspection are written into the specification.
Steel bracing for global stiffness
When the problem is the building as a whole, for example storey drift that is too large in an earthquake, strengthening members one by one is often not enough. Steel bracing helps here: diagonal steel members are installed within the frame bays to add lateral stiffness and strength.
A study in the journal INERSIA (UNY, 2021) shows this on a three-storey office building in Jakarta damaged by fire. The evaluation found that about 31% of the columns and 32% of the beams needed strengthening. The researchers added steel bracing around the building perimeter to control drift and wrapped the overstressed beams and columns in CFRP. Bracing was chosen because it adds less weight than new shear walls.
Keep in mind that bracing changes the load path. Columns and foundations at the ends of each brace take extra force, so they often need checking or strengthening too. Brace positions also affect windows and circulation.
Comparing structural strengthening methods
| Aspect | Concrete jacketing | CFRP | Steel bracing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main purpose | Member strength | Bending, shear, confinement | Lateral stiffness and strength |
| Added weight | Large | Very small | Moderate |
| Space lost | Larger members | Almost none | Part of frame bay closed |
| Fire performance | Good | Needs special protection | Needs protection |
| Disruption during work | High | Low | Moderate |
This table is a general picture, not a rule. Many buildings use a combination, as in the example above.
Questions to ask before choosing
- What is actually lacking: member strength, ductility or global stiffness?
- Will the building stay in use during the works? CFRP is usually the least disruptive.
- What are the environment and fire risk in that area?
- Can the foundations take the extra load or force?
- What about access, installer availability and long-term maintenance?
Every choice must be backed by calculations from a competent structural engineer, following SNI 2847:2019 for concrete, SNI 1726:2019 for seismic design, and specific guides such as ACI 440.2R for FRP. Jacket sizes, the number of CFRP layers and bracing sections are always specific to each building.
Conclusion
Good strengthening starts with the right diagnosis. Jacketing suits cases that need a large strength increase, CFRP suits tight space and weight limits, and steel bracing suits buildings that lack overall stiffness. If your building has changed use, been damaged or needs re-evaluation, start with a structural audit and assessment so the strengthening actually solves the problem.
This article provides general information. Every project still needs to be analysed and calculated by a competent structural or geotechnical engineer, in line with the applicable SNI codes and regulations.
Sources
- ACI 440.2R-17: Guide for the Design and Construction of Externally Bonded FRP Systems for Strengthening Concrete Structures (preview)
- Jacketing Techniques for Repair and Rehabilitation of RC Column Structures: A Review – Structural Durability & Health Monitoring
- Evaluasi dan Retrofit Struktur Gedung Beton Bertulang Akibat Kebakaran – INERSIA (UNY), 2021

