Key points
- A rebound hammer reads surface hardness, not compressive strength directly.
- Core drilling measures actual compressive strength, but cores are limited because each leaves a hole.
- Hammer readings can estimate strength only when correlated with core results.
- SNI 2847:2019 clause 26.12.4 uses the average of three cores as the basis for accepting concrete.
Rebound hammer tests and core drilling are the two most common ways to find out the concrete strength of an existing building, especially when drawings and test records are incomplete. They are often used together but do different jobs: one is fast and non-destructive, the other is more reliable but leaves a hole. This article explains how each works, its strengths and its limits.
When concrete in an older building needs checking
Owners usually need concrete data only when something is planned or has happened, for example:
- plans to add a floor or change the use of a space to one with heavier loads;
- a technical review for an SLF renewal;
- damage from fire, earthquakes or reinforcement corrosion;
- cylinder tests during construction that fell below the specified strength;
- an old building with no structural drawings or material records.
In each case the engineer needs a compressive strength that reflects the real concrete in order to recheck the structure's capacity.
The rebound hammer: fast, but it only reads the surface
A rebound hammer (Schmidt hammer) is pressed against the concrete until a spring-loaded mass strikes and bounces back. The rebound number reflects the hardness of the surface, not the compressive strength directly. In Indonesia the method follows SNI ASTM C805:2012.
Points to observe, as summarised in technical material from the Directorate General of Human Settlements (Cipta Karya):
- each test location has at least 10 readings, spaced at least 25 mm apart;
- plaster and skim coats are removed down to the concrete itself;
- honeycombed, porous or scaled areas are avoided;
- readings more than 6 units from the average are discarded, and if more than two are discarded the whole set is repeated.
The advantages are clear: it is cheap, quick, non-destructive and can cover many members. Its weakness is that results are affected by surface condition, moisture, carbonation, hammer orientation and aggregate type. That is why the rebound hammer is best used to compare uniformity between areas and to choose where to take cores, not to set the compressive strength.
Core drilling: measuring actual strength
Core drilling removes a cylinder of concrete from the member with a diamond bit, which is then crushed in a laboratory. Field coring in Indonesia follows SNI 2492:2018, which is aligned with ASTM C42.
Factors that affect how reliable a core result is:
- Size: the diameter must be large enough relative to the maximum aggregate size, and a length-to-diameter ratio close to 2 is preferred.
- Location: bars must be avoided, so reinforcement is scanned first. Cores that cut bars give less representative results and reduce the member's capacity.
- Moisture and handling: the moisture in the sample and vibration during drilling both influence strength.
- Correction factors: core results are adjusted (for example using ACI 214.4R) for length-to-diameter ratio, diameter, moisture condition and drilling damage.
Because each core leaves a hole, the number of cores is kept to what is needed, and holes must be filled promptly with a suitable repair material.
Hammer test vs core drilling at a glance
| Aspect | Rebound hammer | Core drilling |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Surface hardness | Compressive strength |
| Nature of test | Non-destructive | Semi-destructive |
| Number of points | Many, quick | Limited |
| Reliability for strength | Low on its own | High |
| Main role | Map uniformity, choose core locations | Basis for strength values |
Why rebound readings need calibrating against cores
The best approach uses both. Hammer readings are taken across many members to map weaker and stronger areas. Cores are then taken at a few representative locations, with hammer readings at the same spots. From these pairs the engineer builds a correlation specific to that building, so hammer readings elsewhere can be interpreted more reliably.
The Cipta Karya material also stresses that non-destructive testing cannot replace coring, and that rebound readings can estimate strength only when correlated with core results.
Tip: Ask for a test report that marks every test point on a plan, with photos and surface conditions. This record is very useful when the building is inspected again years later.
Interpreting core results
Where cylinder results during construction were low, SNI 2847:2019 clause 26.12.4 gives acceptance criteria: concrete in the area tested is considered structurally adequate if the average of three cores is at least 85% of f'c and no single core is below 75% of f'c.
For older buildings assessed for a new use, core results more often feed a structural re-analysis. The tested strength goes into calculations that check whether columns, beams and slabs can carry the intended loads. This analysis must be done by a competent engineer, as the outcome depends on each building's structural system and loads. For buildings affected by fire, see our article on structural assessment after fire.
Conclusion
The rebound hammer is quick and inexpensive for mapping concrete uniformity, while core drilling gives a compressive strength you can rely on. To understand concrete in an older building, the two work best together, with hammer readings calibrated against cores. To plan a testing programme and capacity review for your building, see our structural audit and assessment service.
This article provides general information. Every project still needs to be analysed and calculated by a competent structural or geotechnical engineer, in line with the applicable SNI codes and regulations.

